|
WASHINGTON -- The number of women seeking office
in state legislatures declined over the last
election cycle, continuing a 12-year pattern
that women's advocates and political analysts
say could quickly erode the unprecedented number
of women in the 109th US Congress and accelerate
a recent drop in the number of women holding
statewide offices. Since 1992, called "The
Year of the Woman" because of a historic influx
of women in the House, the number of women
running for state legislative office has dipped
from 2,375 to 2,220 in last year's elections,
according to statistics kept by the Center for
American Women and Politics at Rutgers
University. Political analysts and female
lawmakers attribute the steady decline to
cultural biases and term limits.
Women's groups fear that unless more women
run for state legislatures -- which have served
as a political springboard for statewide and
federal campaigns for politicians, such as
Republican Olympia Snowe, Maine's senior
senator -- female representation in higher
levels of government will stagnate or decline.
"Even though we've made significant gains,
it's a mile wide and an inch deep," said
Representative Debbie Wasserman Schultz, a
Florida Democrat who made the jump last year
from the state Legislature to Congress. "There
has not been enough focus on building women
leaders to replace us" when female state
legislators move up to higher office, she said.
"It is troubling to see this declining trend.
If anything, the trend should be increasing,"
Snowe said. "It's the 21st century. I didn't
expect it to be taking a U-turn."
Compared with the 1990s, specialists on women
in politics say, the importance of national
security issues and continued perceptions among
some voters -- as well as some potential female
candidates -- that women should be caring for
their families have limited participation.
"One of the negative stereotypes that hurts
women candidates is national security," said
Harrison Hickman, who did polling for Democratic
senatorial candidate Inez Tenenbaum, who lost a
2004 race in South Carolina. "I don't think
there's any question but that the national
security issue on the agenda made it more
difficult for [Tenenbaum] to run this year."
But he said the landscape could change if the
public's priorities shift to such matters as
Social Security and Medicaid. The national worry
over healthcare and economic security helped
women in 1992, he said, and next year, "you
could see a gathering storm on the horizon that
could be beneficial to women."
Women comprise a record 14.8 percent of
Congress, with 79 seats, and have risen to
leadership positions in recent years. But
analysts say no female challenger won a US
Senate seat last year, and the percentage of
women holding statewide elected office, such as
governors, attorneys general, and US senators,
has dropped since 1999, from 27.6 percent to 25
percent this year.
"We're really kind of stuck," said Debbie Walsh,
director of the Center for American Women and
Politics. "What keeping them from running?
That's the issue we're worried about." If more
women do not start running for lower-level
office, "we're not going to see the trickle-up
we want to see," she said.
Political analysts and women's advocates
attribute the trend to voters and the candidates
themselves.
"I do think that for certain folks, my being
a woman may have been a factor in their reason
not to vote for me," said Representative
Stephanie Herseth, a South Dakota Democrat.
"When national security is a focus, there's a
tendency to be more comfortable with male
candidates."
Also, women themselves seem to be less
confident of their ability to serve in elected
office, even when they have the same
qualifications on paper as a man, Walsh said.
Research published in the American Journal of
Political Science and cited by the center
indicated that men are more likely to come to an
independent conclusion that they will run for
office, while women must be persuaded to do so.
The statistics indicated that 11 percent of
women run for state legislative office on their
own initiative, compared with 37 percent of male
candidates. Conversely, 18 percent of male
candidates had to be talked into running, while
37 percent of women needed to be recruited.
"Most women don't wake up and say, 'I'm going
to run for the Senate someday.' Men do," said
Karen White, political director of EMILY's List,
which funds Democratic female candidates.
Pat Carpenter, president of WISH List, which
promotes abortion rights for Republican female
candidates, said she had found that many women
were running successful businesses and had not
thought about running for office. Alarmed by the
drop-off in female candidates, both EMILY's List
and WISH List have expanded their missions in
recent years to recruit women to run for
lower-level offices and to train them to conduct
campaigns.
Family obligations, too, affect the number of
women running for office, analysts and female
officials say, but they note that the barrier
may come more from the public's impression of
mothers or single women in office than from the
women's competing demands of family and
lawmaking.
"Certainly, there continue to be issues for
women in all careers as they struggle to balance
work and family obligations," said former
governor Jane Swift, who gave birth to twins
while in office. "There is some research
[showing] that people perceive that women with
young children won't be as committed to a
political job."
Wasserman Schultz said her opponent, a woman,
tried to suggest she was a "bad mother" for
running for Congress when she had three small
children. The effort backfired, said Wasserman
Schultz, who won the seat handily.
Women's success in getting elected to a state
legislature does not seem to be connected to
whether the state votes Democratic or
Republican. According to statistics compiled by
the Center for American Women and Politics,
states that tend to vote for Democrats are not
generally more expected to elect women to a
state legislature than conservative-leaning
states. Republican states including Wyoming,
Montana, and Idaho all have a higher percentage
of female state legislators than do
Massachusetts and New York, for example. With a
Legislature that is 24.5 percent female,
Massachusetts ranks 20th in the nation in the
representation of women in the State House.
But the pool of female candidates is
shrinking, and the existence of term limits in
17 states means that it is even more critical to
bring new female candidates into the mix, Walsh
said. Female incumbents, like their male
counterparts, are better positioned to win than
challengers, but when incumbents are barred from
running again, political parties and activists
need to find more women ready and able to run
for those jobs, she said.
Female lawmakers and political recruiters
said the parties and elected women themselves
need to work harder to recruit more women to
run.
Wasserman Schultz said she made a point of
recruiting another woman to run for her seat in
the state Legislature when term limits required
her to leave. That candidate won.
"My attitude is, I've gotten where I want to
go through hard work and through a lot of help
and positive support around me," she said. "Many
women are so focused on getting themselves up
the ladder, they forget to reach behind them."
|