As Sen. John Kerry learned in last year's
presidential race, it's not always easy
defending a congressional voting record.
The Massachusetts Democrat got tagged with
being a "flip-flopper" for seemingly conflicting
votes on a range of issues, most notably the
Iraq war. Now it's Maine's two Republican
senators who are feeling similar heat, having to
defend votes in favor of the budget outline for
the next fiscal year.
The budget, which won approval in the Senate
52-47, contained cuts to programs that made both
Sens. Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins uneasy.
The most contentious of these are planned
reductions for Medicaid health insurance for the
poor. The budget also advances the agenda of
those who would like to open Alaska's Arctic
National Wildlife Refuge to oil drilling,
something Snowe and Collins oppose.
Those are just the highlights, really, of a
budget that has plenty to dislike, not the least
of which is the fact that, despite some painful
cuts in Medicaid and other programs, the budget
makes little significant progress on reducing
the size of the federal deficit.
What the budget did have, however, were some
provisions that will help Bath Iron Works as it
competes for contracts to build the Navy's next
generation of destroyers. The budget alters the
funding mechanism for the ships to allow more to
be ordered up front. It also expresses
congressional disapproval of the idea of having
a single shipyard build the destroyers. There
are currently two slated to do so.
So, despite much that the senators disliked
about the budget, they gave it their approval.
Its passage is significant in the Senate,
because it means that future spending bills will
only require a simple majority rather than the
60 votes it normally takes to end discussion on
a bill.
The vote is a good illustration of the tough
choices a lawmaker sometimes has to make. Issues
are rarely considered in isolation. Instead
they're packaged together in a deliberate
attempt to attract votes from a majority.
In voting for this budget (Maine's two House
members, Democrats Tom Allen and Michael
Michaud, voted against it), Snowe and Collins
put the health of Bath Iron Works ahead of other
issues.
That may give political opponents ammunition,
but it's also defensible. Over time, it's up to
the voters to decide if such decisions were the
right ones.