Anyone who doubts that the United States is
lagging when it comes to upping the fuel economy
standards for cars should look across the ocean - to
China. With a growing population and burgeoning
economy, oil consumption is growing rapidly in
China, the world's second largest car market. This
prompted the State Council, the country's cabinet,
to call for fuel-efficiency standards.
Though the standards are not considered
particularly stringent by Chinese energy experts,
they are stricter than U.S. standards, which haven't
been updated in more than two decades, despite
efforts to do so by Maine's congressional
delegation.
The same week that China announced its new
standards, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
released its 2005 fuel economy guide. The 10 most
fuel-efficient cars are imports, with eight coming
from Japan and two from Germany. The worst
performers were typically made in America.
In China, nearly 5 million barrels of oil are
consumed per day, according to 2002 figures from the
Energy Information Administration. By contrast, the
United States consumes more than 19 million barrels
a day. When the population of each country is taken
into consideration, the difference is more
staggering. In China, slightly less than
4 barrels of oil are consumed daily per 1,000
people. In the United States, daily oil consumption
per 1,000 people is nearly 68 barrels.
If the Chinese government has decided that
improving automobile fuel efficiency is necessary to
reduce their growing oil consumption, such a
conclusion should have been reached here a long time
ago. It hasn't been.
The Chinese standards require that cars and
trucks get between 19 and 38 miles per gallon by
2005 and between 21 and 43 miles per gallon by 2005.
Only 79 percent of new U.S. cars on the market and
27 percent of light trucks meet China's 2005
standard. Only 19 percent of U.S. cars and 14
percent of trucks would meet the 2008 standard.
America's best-selling vehicle for 22 years, Ford's
F-150 pickup gets an average of 16 miles per gallon
and would not meet either standard.
The U.S. standards are calculated based on the
average fuel consumption of the entire fleet sold by
an automaker (so one hybrid model can lower the
entire fleet average). Under the Chinese system,
each model sold must meet the standards.
Sens. Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins have
repeatedly introduced a bill that would not just add
a mile or two a gallon to SUV and light truck
performance, as the president's plan did over three
years. They would include those large vehicles in
the standard for cars by demanding increases in fuel
performance beginning when the president's plan
ends,
in 2008, and achieving 27.5 mpg by 2011. The
estimated savings from the Senate plan, when fully
in place, would equal 1 million barrels of oil a
day.
Their plan failed in favor of the president's
small increase. The result is continued reliance on
imported oil and, as oil prices show no sign of
dropping, continued expensive fill-ups for American
drivers.