WEEKLY SENATE UPDATE

By U.S. Senator Olympia J. Snowe

For the week of August 19 through August 26, 2005

BEYOND BRAC

 

This week’s decisions by the Base Realignment and Closure (BRAC) Commission brought joy and relief for some in our state, and bitter disappointment for others.  We could not be more pleased for the men and women of Kittery and Limestone, but the shocking decision to close Brunswick Naval Air Station leaves many of us with little desire to celebrate.  The events of this week will continue to resonate in Maine for decades to come, so now is a time not only to evaluate what has happened, but to look ahead to what the BRAC Commission’s decisions will mean for our national security and the affected communities.   

Last Wednesday, the Commission rightfully validated the indispensable military value of the Portsmouth Naval Shipyard.  To the people of the Kittery-Portsmouth region, this is an overwhelming and well-deserved victory and an affirmation of the compelling case for the shipyard, written by the unflagging dedication to excellence of its people.  Kittery-Portsmouth has once again asserted its prominent place in the Navy’s future. 

We have said all along that it would be unconscionable to close the only shipyard in the country – public or private – that puts submarines to sea ahead of schedule while saving millions of dollars on every job.  Now, the nation’s gold standard of industrial shipyard efficiency will continue to shine for many, many years to come.

On the following day, the BRAC Commission decided to not only keep the Defense Finance Accounting Service (DFAS) Center in Limestone open, but to expand it to not less than 600 positions, nearly doubling the number of jobs at the site.  This was one of the brightest days in recent memory for the people of Aroostook County, who have contributed so much to our nation, and suffered so greatly from the base closure process in the past.  By deciding to expand operations at Limestone, the Commission affirmed the critical value of a workforce of the highest quality and greatest efficiency, sending a message that excellence does matter. 

It is those who work at DFAS Limestone who made the case that was recognized and accepted by the commission – that Limestone should be expanded as a DFAS “Center of Excellence.”  I applaud the BRAC Commission for underscoring that Limestone is a pillar of our defense administration infrastructure, and I appreciate the Commission effectively overturned the Department’s plan to collapse Limestone and 25 other facilities into just three locations.  

Unfortunately, during the same week in which Portsmouth and Limestone were vindicated, the Commission voted to close Brunswick Naval Air Station.  This decision is deeply disturbing, because it ignores the clear and repeated recommendations from the Defense Department, especially the Northern Command, citing the unique strategic location and military value of Brunswick, not to mention the common recognition of the excellence of the men and women who have served there.

I agree with Commissioner Coyle, who voted against closing Brunswick, when he said that “it makes no sense” for the Commission to say, on the one hand, that the Navy will continue to need access to an air base in the Northeast, but then go on to vote to close Brunswick – the last remaining air base in the Northeast.  And I agree with Defense Department when it said that Brunswick provides this nation with irreplaceable military value in our post-9-11 environment.  To be sure, we face new, emerging threats, and they include the potential for terrorists to use the North Atlantic shipping lanes to smuggle weapons of mass destruction into our harbors and ports.

Nonetheless, starting today, we move forward with the same sustained urgency and tenacity that we have brought all along to this process.  In addition to supporting any legislative effort to disapprove of this recommendation, I will work to seize each and every opportunity available for economic redevelopment.   

I will work closely to support the local and state partnership to help lead the economic redevelopment of this region.  I will also work closely with my colleagues to support the newly created all-star team of economic leaders that the Governor is rightly assembling in the Office of Economic Redevelopment to plan for comprehensive and effective recovery for each region.  

Just as I did for the Loring closure, I will introduce legislation that requires the federal government to give us free of charge the land at Brunswick that DoD is abandoning, rather than forcing our hard hit communities to pay fair market value for it.  In addition, I will ensure that the new “HUBZones” I worked to create last year are fully utilized.  As Chair of the Small Business Committee, I successfully wrote legislation that included designating any area subject to the BRAC process as a HUBZone area for a period of five year, an important avenue for assistance. 

Finally, I will work with every federal agency, such as the Office of Economic Adjustment within the DoD and the Economic Development Administration, which has provided grants in past BRAC rounds for such items as planning and technical assistance, infrastructure improvement, and revolving loan funds for private business development.  Wherever I find that these existing federal programs are insufficient, my colleagues and I will look to bolster them through the legislative process.

As we begin to shift from battling base closure to winning economic recovery, let me be clear: we will make sure that the government honors each and every commitment it has made to communities like ours – every last resource will be identified and brought to bear to repair our state.  This difficult decision affects all of us – we are in this together and so we will work together tirelessly to leave no option unexplored for the men and women of these facilities and communities that have contributed so much to America.